Best eyeliner 2019

Which is the best eyeliner?

View the best offeri

Review of the 10 best eyeliners

The top 10 list of the best eyeliners compares various manufacturers and prices

Review10Best compares the best eyeliners and nominates the one from Maybelline, Consumer Products Division of L'Oréal USA S/D, Inc. as the best eyeliner. In our eyeliners review, you can read more about our experiences we made with the different eyeliners and follow our recommendation on which eyeliner to buy in 2019. With the eyeliner comparison, you can be sure to buy the best eyeliner on the market and save a lot of money if you buy it online.


Table of contents

  1. Read the ultimate eyeliner buying guide
  2. View our eyeliner picks and see how they rank in the top list
  3. Watch recommended videos about eyeliners
  4. More about eyeliners on the web

Go to the ranking
(skip buying guide)


eyeliners: A complete buying guide

All you need to know before buying a great eyeliner

Picture of a eyeliner

Nothing defines and shapes the eyes of a lady more like good eyeliners. Be it for casual outings or more formal occasions, there is always the right eyeliner to give your eyes that great look that they deserve. Eyeliners come in different types to fit the different skin types. You will find tips on how to choose the best eyeliner to suit your skin type.

What are eyeliners?

Eyeliners are makeups worn around the eyes especially on the lashes. They shape and define the eyes, giving them very good looks. Applying the right kind of eyeliners in the right way can give your eyes the best look for any kind of occasion or event you wish to attend, irrespective of the look we decide on, whether it is a casual outing or a more formal one. They come in different forms like powder, liquid and gel forms. Go through the list of guides provide below to help you make the perfect choice on which of these forms will be best at any time.

Why should you buy a good eyeliner?

Whichever way you would love to use them, to add more colors around the eyes, to make the eyes appear smaller or bigger, rounder or flatter, you can always count on the best eyeliners to do the dazzling trick. Using the right eyeliner gives the eye firm line and accentuates the impression of a more charming eye. This in turn will make the face look fresher and more attractive. It is arguably a must in every ladies’ makeup.

Another picture of a eyeliner
How to choose the right eyeliner?

Choosing the best eyeliner for you is as important as getting one. Different eyeliners do have their different effect on the overall appearance of the eye. You can count on the following tips to help you get the best eyeliner for your eyes easily:

  • Smudging: Make sure you go for eyeliners that will not smudge so easily. You won’t want your eyes to be messed up unexpectedly right in the middle of a party, or a meeting, or an occasion.
  • Skin Type: You need to know your skin type before choosing any eyeliner. If you are having an oily skin type then you should avoid using liquid eyeliners only. You can apply the liquid eyeliner along with some powder eyeliners to absorb so of the grease that will ooze out of your skin but using the pencil eyeliner and powder eyeliner will be best for you. Others with normal skin type or dry skin type may use any kind of eyeliners they may choose to.
  • The Occasion: Choose your eyeliner based on the occasion. Pencil eyeliners are best for casual outings. The liquid eyeliners would do for formal events.
What is the best kind of eyeliner?

Below are quick guides to help you decide on what type of eyeliner to buy:

  • Liquid Eyeliners: Liquid eyeliners are best for ladies with flawless skin or those who can create one with foundation and concealer! This type usually accentuates the eyelashes with pointed edges and sharp strokes. It’s great for formal occasions and not for casual outings. Although it is arguably the best kind of eyeliners, you will need a great deal of dexterity to apply them perfectly because, unlike other types that can be rubbed off easily, these ones require a special formula to rob them off, so every mistake will be a nightmare.
  • Pencil Eyeliner: They are the most common type of eyeliners. Although they are not long lasting, pencil eyeliners are quite cheap and easier to apply than the other types of makeups, plus they can be removed easily. Unlike the liquid and gel eyeliner, the pencil liner cannot produce sharp strokes and thus, cannot be used to create the cat eye effect.
  • Gel Eyeliner: Gel eyeliners are in between the liquid and pencil eyeliners and offer the same benefits that both offers. They last long too but are a bit expensive to maintain. They can be worn for both casual and formal events.
  • Powder Eyeliner: This eyeliner allows you to apply different colors to around your eyes. You can damp the bristles of a thin angled brush and dip it into any color of your preferred eye shadow. Like the pencil eyeliner, the powder eyeliners cannot produce sharp strokes too.
  • Gel Pencil Eyeliner: Gel pencils appear to have a darker and sharper effect than any other type of eyeliners. They can produce the sharp stroke too like their gel counterparts. Although they seem to be more expensive, they are easier to use than the liquid and gel eyeliners.
…are you ready for our top picks?

Top 10 list of eyeliners (April 2019)

Our top 10 list shows how manufacturers and their eyeliners rank and which eyeliner is the best.
Top choicei TOP 1
Image of Maybelline, Consumer Products Division of L'Oréal USA S/D, Inc. 10054902 eyeliner
Maybelline Eyestudio Master Precise All Day Liquid Eyeliner Makeup, Black, 0.034 fl. oz.i
  • REMOVE MAYBELLINE MAKEUP WITH MICELLAR WATER: Use Garnier Micellar Water as a gentle…
  • MAYBELLINE HAS WHAT YOU NEED to create any look--foundation, bb creams, concealers…
  • MAYBELLINE IS THE EYE EXPERT: Whatever your signature eye look, whether natural…
starting from $6.80i
(0 reviews)
Buy nowi
Value deali TOP 2
Image of L'Oreal Paris Cosmetics FPS-173225 eyeliner
L'Oréal Paris Makeup Infallible Never Fail Pencil Eyeliner, Black, 0.008 oz.i
  • PERFECT TO PAIR WITH: Voluminous Original Volume Building Mascara, uniquely formulated…
  • BECAUSE YOU'RE WORTH IT: L'Oreal Paris Makeup helps you create the look you want…
  • CREATE YOUR PERFECT EYE MAKEUP LOOK with our collection of Voluminous mascaras, achieve…
starting from $7.89i
(0 reviews)
Buy nowi
TOP 3
Image of Maybelline 10012540 eyeliner
Maybelline Unstoppable Eyeliner, Onyx, 0.01 oz.i
  • REMOVE MAYBELLINE MAKEUP WITH MICELLAR WATER: Use Garnier Micellar Water as a gentle…
  • MAYBELLINE HAS WHAT YOU NEED to create any look--foundation, bb creams, concealers…
  • MAYBELLINE IS THE EYE EXPERT: Whatever your signature eye look, whether natural or…
starting from $5.50i
(0 reviews)
Buy nowi
TOP 4
Image of Revlon ARV-2132 eyeliner
Revlon ColorStay Skinny Liquid Eyeliner, Black Outi
  • Ophthalmologist tested
  • 0.1mm skinny tip applicator
  • Long lasting color stay formula won't smudge, smear or fade for all day wear
starting from $4.99i
(381 reviews)
Buy nowi
TOP 5
Image of Vogue Effects Ltd 1 eyeliner
Eyeliner Stamp – Wingliner by Lovoir/Vogue Effects Black, Waterproof Make Up, Smudgeproof, Winged Long Lasting Liquid Eye liner Pen, Vamp Style Wing, 2 Pens In A Pack (10mm Classic)i
  • Ophthalmologist tested
  • 0.1mm skinny tip applicator
  • Long lasting color stay formula won't smudge, smear or fade for all day wear
starting from $13.97i
(0 reviews)
Buy nowi
TOP 6
Image of bareMinerals 169625 eyeliner
bareMinerals Long Lasting Eyeliner, Absolute Black, 0.012 Ouncei
  • It richly pigmented color and is infused with a soothing, nourishing blend of minerals…
  • Includes a built-in sharpener plus an ergonomically angled smudge tip for smooth,…
  • The mineral-rich formula stays soft and creamy for blending, then sets to a long-wearing…
starting from $7.95i
(0 reviews)
Buy nowi
TOP 7
Image of L'Oreal Paris Cosmetics 10060450 eyeliner
L'Oreal Paris Infallible Gel Lacquer Liner, Blackest Black, 0.09 Fluid Ouncei
  • Flawless, fade-free wear
  • 24HR long wear
  • Gel formula for smooth application
starting from $7.69i
(0 reviews)
Buy nowi
TOP 8
Image of Neutrogena Cosmetics 12482 eyeliner
Neutrogena Nourishing Eyeliner Pencil, Brushed Pewter 20, .01 Oz.i
  • Includes built-in sharpener and smudger
  • Nourishing olive oil, shea butter, and light diffusers
  • Glides on smoothly and lasts all day
starting from $8.86i
(0 reviews)
Buy nowi
TOP 9
Image of stila STL-382 eyeliner
stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner, Dark Brown (Rich Chocolate)i
  • Thin marker-like tip is easy to use
  • Lasts all day
  • Goes on smoothly without skipping, smudging, or pulling
starting from $22.00i
(0 reviews)
Buy nowi
TOP 10
Image of iMethod A1 eyeliner
iMethod Wing Eyeliner Stamp - 2 Pens Left & Right Dual Ended Liquid Winged Eye Liner Pen, Perfect Winged Cat Eye Look, Waterproof, Smudgeproof and Sweatproof, Vamp Style Wing, No Dipping Requiredi
  • 100% SATISFACTION GUARANTEE - We offer a worry-free LIFETIME warranty and friendly…
  • STAY ALL DAY - The formula is long-lasting, waterproof and smudge-proof. It does…
  • PERFECT SYMMETRICAL WING EYELINER - Each set contains 2 eyeliner pens, one for your…
starting from $11.97i
(0 reviews)
Buy nowi

i Price incl. VAT., exkl. shipping. Price may vary. Last Update. 2019/04/24 22:45 o'clock. Affiliate link. We participate in the Amazon Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program that enables us to earn commissions by linking to Amazon. There are no additional costs for you. For the top 10 list we consider only products that are available on Amazon while the ranking is based on factors such as customer reviews, number of sales and keyword.


Recommended Video about the best eyeliners


Further resources about eyeliners