Best sandwich toaster 2020

Which is the best sandwich toaster?

View the best offer

Review of the 10 best sandwich toasters

The top 10 list of the best sandwich toasters compares various manufacturers and prices

Review10Best compares the best sandwich toasters and nominates the one by Cuisinart as the best sandwich toaster. In our sandwich toasters review, you can read more about our experiences we made with the different sandwich toasters and follow our recommendation on which sandwich toaster to buy in 2020. With the sandwich toaster comparison, you can be sure to buy the best sandwich toaster on the market and save a lot of money if you buy it online.


Table of contents

  1. Read the ultimate sandwich toaster buying guide
  2. View our sandwich toaster picks and see how they rank in the top list
  3. Watch recommended videos about sandwich toasters

Go to the ranking
(skip buying guide)


Best sandwich toasters: A complete buying guide

All you need to know before buying a great sandwich toaster

Picture of a sandwich toaster

A good sandwich toaster is a welcome addition to any kitchen. Great for making toasted sandwiches and all kinds of other foods, the best sandwich toasters are versatile appliances that produce some seriously tasty dishes. To help you find the right sandwich toaster for your kitchen, check out the handy buying guide below, as it has all the info you need to find a suitable model.

What are sandwich toasters?

A sandwich toaster, also called a toastie maker or sandwich maker, is a type of kitchen appliance that makes toasted sandwiches and other foods. Unlike a traditional toaster, it uses large iron plates to heat, toast, and seal the sandwich. Sandwich makers are popular for making toasties, which is basically a sealed toasted sandwich with a hot filling inside.

Why should you buy a good sandwich toaster?

Toasted sandwiches are a delicious snack and very simple to make using the best sandwich toaster, while it can also be used to make all kinds of other awesome snacks like toasted paninis. You can use sweet or savoury fillings between the bread, while some devices can be used as a waffle iron to make other sweet treats and snacks. Plus, most sandwich toasters are very affordable.

Another picture of a sandwich toaster
How to choose the right sandwich toaster?

Here are some things to consider when buying the best sandwich maker:

  • Size: The size of plates determines the type of toasted sandwich you can make, so always check the size and depth to make sure it's big enough for your preferences. Those with deeper plates allow for more fillings to be used and generally make bigger toasties, while some are designed to make much thinner sandwiches and paninis.
  • Maintenance: One big reason that toastie makers become less popular was the mess they leave behind, with all kinds of melted foods stuck to the plates. Thankfully, modern appliances are usually easier to clean, with non-stick plates being one of the main things to look for to make cleaning easier. Some even come with removable plates that are dishwasher safe, making cleaning even simpler.
  • Versatility: Some sandwich toasters make just toasties but many can be used for other foods like paninis, waffles, or even preparing meat and vegetables. The iron plates generate a lot of heat so can often double as a grill, although features like changeable plates are recommended if you want a versatile appliance.
What is the best kind of sandwich toaster?

Here are some of the main types of sandwich toasters available to buy:

  • Concave Sandwich Toasters: This type of sandwich toaster has concaved plates, making it best for the classic toastie with a hot melted filling. They aren’t the best for other foods but are great for making toasted sandwiches with various fillings.
  • Flat Sandwich Toasters: Toastie makers with flat plates great much thinner toasties, so they can’t be stuffed with too many fillings or they will leak. They are great for making paninis and can double as a hot grill for meats and vegetables too.
  • Interchangeable Sandwich Toasters: Offers all the above thanks to interchangeable iron plates, letting you make all kinds of toasted sandwiches and other snacks. These often come with waffle iron attachments for making waffles, pancakes, and other sweet treats.
…are you ready for our top picks?

Top 10 list of sandwich toasters (June 2020)

Our top 10 list shows how manufacturers and their sandwich toasters rank and which sandwich toaster is the best.
Ad We may earn commissions from purchases made through links on this list.
Top choicei TOP 1
Image of Cuisinart WM-SW2N sandwich toaster
Cuisinart WM-SW2N Dual-Sandwich Nonstick Electric Grilli
  • Measures 9 by 9 by 3-1/2 inches; 3-year limited warranty
  • Red and green indicator lights; also makes French toast and omelets
  • UC LWH: 10.12" x 5.28" x 9.92";MC LWH: 21.77" x 10.63" x…
Buy now on Amazoni
Value deali TOP 2
Image of Brentwood TS-246 sandwich toaster
Brentwood Panini Press and Sandwich Maker Non-Stick, Blacki
  • Easy to carry, locking handle
  • Panini press has power and preheat indicator lights
  • Sandwiches slide right off the non-stick grill plates
Buy now on Amazoni
TOP 3
Image of Proctor Silex 25408Y sandwich toaster
Proctor Silex Sandwich Toaster, Omelet And Turnover Maker, White (25408Y)i
  • Toasty Results, Sandwich After Sandwich: A Warm, Toasty Sandwich Is Always a Good…
  • Indicator Lights: Power on and Preheat Lights Let You Know When It’s Time to…
  • Easy Clean Nonstick Plates: Cleanup Couldn’t Be Easier Thanks to the Nonstick…
Buy now on Amazoni
TOP 4
Image of BLACK+DECKER WM2000SD sandwich toaster
Black+Decker 3-in-1 WM2000SD 3-in-1 Waffle, Grill & Sandwich Maker, Compact Design, Black/Silveri
  • Stainless steel accents
  • Nonstick + dishwasher-safe plates for easy cleanup!
  • Grease run-off channels
Buy now on Amazoni
TOP 5
Image of OSTBA  sandwich toaster
OSTBA Sandwich Maker, Toaster and Electric Panini Press with Non-stick plates, LED Indicator Lights, Cool Touch Handle, Blacki
  • 2-Year Quality Warranty: We offer 2-year quality warranty, welcome to contact us…
  • Indicator Lights and Cool Touch Handle: Power on and preheat lights let you know…
  • Compact Design&Storage: Built for small spaces and outdoor use, the sandwich…
Buy now on Amazoni
TOP 6
Image of George Foreman GR10B sandwich toaster
George Foreman 2-Serving Classic Plate Electric Indoor Grill and Panini Press, Black, GR10Bi
  • Drip Tray - The dishwasher-safe drip tray collects excess fat and grease so you don’t…
  • Fat-Removing Slope - It’s the sure sign of a George Foreman Grill. The sloped…
  • George Tough Nonstick Coating - There’s a lot to love about this nonstick coating.…
Buy now on Amazoni
TOP 7
Image of GOTHAM STEEL 2108 sandwich toaster
GOTHAM STEEL 2108 Maker, Toaster and Electric Panini Grill with Ultra Nonstick Copper Surface Makes 2 Sandwiches in Minutes with Virtually No Clean Up, Seals, Largei
  • 1 YEAR – Gotham Steel is built for years of use and backed by a 1 year lim…
  • COMPACT & PORTABLE - perfect for dorm rooms and all sized kitchens
  • PERFECT SANDWICHES EVERY TIME – toasts the bread and seals with a diagonal…
Buy now on Amazoni
TOP 8
Image of Hamilton Beach 25430 sandwich toaster
Hamilton Beach Sandwich Maker, Makes Omelettes and Grilled Cheese, 4 Inch, Easy to Store (25430), BLACKi
  • Power on/ preheat lights
  • Power on and ready to cook preheat light: the power on light lets you know the unit…
  • Space-saving storage and compact design: Lock the handle and store This compact appliance…
Buy now on Amazoni
TOP 9
Image of Hamilton Beach 25490A sandwich toaster
Hamilton Beach Dual Breakfast Sandwich Maker with Timer, Silver (25490A)i
  • Included Components: Quick and Easy Recipes
  • Easy Clean Up: All Removable Parts on This Breakfast Maker Are Dishwasher Safe.
  • Great Gift: Perfect Gift for Christmas, Birthdays, Father's Day, Mother's Day, Graduation,…
Buy now on Amazoni
TOP 10
Image of Hamilton Beach 25462Z sandwich toaster
Hamilton Beach Electric Panini Press Grill With Locking Lid, Opens 180 Degrees For Any Sandwich Thickness, Nonstick 8" X 10" Grids, Red (25462Z)i
  • Stylish Red finish: panini press looks great on any counter
  • Upright storage: easily Fits in your kitchen cabinet or discreetly on your count…
  • Top lid lock: lock panini press lid to create an easy bruschetta or open face sa…
Buy now on Amazoni

iAffiliate link. We participate in the Amazon Associates Program. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. There are no additional costs for you. For the top 10 list we consider only products that are available on Amazon while the ranking is based on factors such as customer reviews, number of sales and keyword. Last Update. 2020/06/05 19:28 o'clock.


Recommended Video about the best sandwich toasters